About Growth & Justice

  • Growth & Justice is a progressive think tank committed to making Minnesota's economy simultaneously more prosperous and fair. We believe that at a time of deep partisan division, Minnesotans can unite around one goal: a strong and growing state economy that provides a decent standard of living for all.

« Reaching across the river... and the aisle | Main | Minnesota’s Business Taxes, Climate – Not So Bad »

January 16, 2009

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Dennis

So, what are you saying? The taxpayers are the employer, and the employer needs to give the state a raise? I guess I don't understand your blog. Or, am I spot on as to what you're saying? Any solutions to the budget besides stealing more from me? Or, just hollow rhetoric of your own? Just FYI, my 0.98% (that's less than 1% for you math genious) anual pay-raise in light of a 5.8% cost of living increase gave me a whopping 4.8% cut in pay this year. (last year it was no raise and a 3. something cost of living increase) In the last three years I have effectively received a nearly 10% pay cut. It's time for the state accept a cut in pay once in a while too. Been to the grocery store lately? I can fit $40 worth of groceries into one paper bag real easy. That's just eggs, milk, bread, PB&J types of food, not the big ticket items such as steak. A $1.39 buys me one whole can of tomatoes by the way. I get a cut in pay and the state should get a raise from me? No, I don't think so.

Craig Westover

As I've written before -- being critical of the Republican Party -- Republicans champion the idea that "government must live within its means" — just like Minnesota families. Unfortunately, the "make government live within its means" mantra is not a principle, and government is not a family. Unlike a family, government doesn't do "fun stuff." Unlike a family, government doesn't earn money and government doesn't create wealth. Families earn and save so they can do more, so they can do fun stuff; government is limited to meeting its constitutional obligations. Period.

Another key difference is that unless the family decides to turn to a life of crime, it cannot raise revenue by taking it from its neighbors -- no matter how rich and undeserving those neighbors might be. Governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed. The operative word is "just." Government cannot assume a power that is not an individual's to consent.

Both Dems and Repubs should scrap the kitchen table analogy and debate the real issue -- limited, constitutional government protecting individual rights or majoritarian non-restrained government acting for a subjective common good; which does Minnesota want to be.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Blog powered by Typepad